New study explores the costs to cocoa farmers of the EU Organic Regulation – and how Fairtrade helps
New EU organic rules, combined with the most extreme cocoa price swings in decades, have made organic cocoa markedly more expensive to produce. How is Fairtrade supporting producers?
A new study found that organic certification fees per tonne of cocoa roughly doubled across cocoa cooperatives surveyed, and that organic value supply chains have changed profoundly in the last two years.
One main reason? The cost of compliance with the EU Organic Regulation (EUOR), which took effect in 2025.
Most cooperatives had to make changes in order to follow the new requirements, which include:
- Membership size and type restrictions, requiring cooperatives to remove members, create new legal entities, or other actions;
- Switch to meeting exact EU organic standards, as opposed to equivalent local or other organic standards;
- Additional internal controls and testing, resulting in administrative burden as well as delays in sales.
At the same time, cooperatives were preparing for the EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR), which tied up the same staff, systems and cash, and cocoa prices went through the most extreme swings in decades.
The new study, conducted by the Research Institute of Organic Agriculture (FiBL) and Fairtrade International and supported by SWISSCO (the Swiss Platform for Sustainable Cocoa), was designed to understand how the EUOR was impacting organic farmers and cooperatives, and therefore also European supply chains. It included an online survey that reached multiple types of producers, including 76 cocoa cooperatives (two-thirds also Fairtrade certified) in 11 countries, covering more than 52,00 organic cocoa farmers.
Here are four takeaways from the study, shared in a recent webinar featuring FiBL researcher Florentine Meinshausen and other Fairtrade experts.
1. Less organic cocoa is coming to Europe.
The research quantified the change in organic cocoa imports to Europe, which fell sharply in 2023 and 2024 as record-high, volatile prices coincided with the transition to the EUOR. While imports rebounded in 2025, EU imports remain 9 percent below the 2018–2022 average – a shortfall of more than 53,000 tonnes of cocoa bean equivalent over 2023–2025.
“We had a perfect storm,” said Yanick Lhommel, Business Development Manager for Cocoa and Sugar at Fairtrade Max Havelaar Switzerland. “Switzerland imports the most organic cocoa per capita of any country in Europe due to high domestic consumption as well as chocolate manufacturing for export, and cocoa shortages caused a huge sourcing challenge in 2023 and 2024."
2. Costs increased significantly – and fell on producers.
Organic certification fees increased to varying degrees. Fees roughly doubled per tonne of cocoa for the cocoa cooperatives surveyed, or when calculated in terms of cost per farmer, they rose by about one-third for the median organisation, and about fivefold for large organisations with more than 2,000 farmers. Internal control costs, however, are at least twice as high as external certification fees. Including external and internal costs, total control costs per farmer rose by 38 percent for the median cocoa organisation.
In addition, residue testing added considerable costs, and any findings resulted in considerable commercial damage, delayed or lost organic shipments. Price volatility, scarcity and side-selling by farmers outside of their cooperatives (especially in 2024) left cooperatives selling overall lower organic volumes to support their higher costs.
3. Fairtrade pricing and Premium bolster organic cooperatives.
Organisations holding organic and Fairtrade certification were comparatively well placed: they receive a guaranteed minimum Fairtrade organic differential paid on top of either the market price or Fairtrade Minimum Price (whichever is higher) and the Fairtrade Premium. Because organic prices do not yet reflect cooperatives’ higher compliance costs, 19 of 27 producer organisations named the Fairtrade Premium as their main or partial source of funding for higher compliance costs.
“Earlier this year, we increased the Fairtrade organic differential by 50 percent, from 300 USD to 450 USD per tonne, to account for those higher compliance costs,” explained Johanna Schmidt, Fairtrade International’s Cocoa Manager. “This helps cooperatives specifically for cocoa sold on both Fairtrade and organic terms.”
The study estimates that, with the higher differential, a typical cooperative can cover its organic control costs and still pass on about 196 USD per tonne to farmers as an organic differential.
4. Most producer organisations intend to stay certified, but need supply chain support.
Just over half of the cocoa organisations surveyed consider the major adjustments behind them; the rest plan to shrink or are unsure whether they can maintain full compliance. Producer representatives warned that small cooperatives exposed to volatility and rising requirements risk giving up certification.
While no cocoa cooperative in the survey gave up EU organic certification completely, almost half reduced the number of farmers in their organisations, resulting in a seven percent drop in EU-organic cocoa farmers.
According to the survey, the drop is even more worrying across all smallholder crops beyond just cocoa: EU-organic farmer numbers fell by 39 percent from 2024 to 2025, mainly due to sharp declines in several very large organisations in Africa. As researcher Florentine Meinshausen noted, “Most don’t exit just the EU organic scheme, but organic production altogether.”
Supply chains should share the cost of organic cocoa
The study also includes recommendations for making organic cocoa viable in the long-term.
- The Fairtrade organic differential of 450 USD per tonne, together with multi-year volume commitments, shared risk and prefinance. Brands and retailers should share the higher cost of organic integrity.
- Better capture organic compliance costs in the cost data Fairtrade uses to set the organic differential, and advance cross-acceptance between organic and Fairtrade standards.
- Producers should monitor their organic compliance costs and contain them through strategic segregation of certification by destination market, strengthen internal control systems, expand income diversification and agroforestry practices – which Fairtrade supports.
- Continue dialogue with policymakers to further simplify and reduce the burdens of the EUOR based on farmer realities. Thanks to the advocacy work of Fairtrade and other organisations, a simplification of the EUOR group rules is due to be finalised by the end of 2026.
Anneke Theunissen, COO of the Fairtrade producer network in Latin America and the Caribbean (CLAC), emphasised why Fairtrade is built with equal ownership and decision-making power for producers. “Requirements from other countries’ laws continue to pile up on producers, and they always come with costs. This study helps us to understand the cost of the EUOR for producers, and to share that with our partners – in supply chains, in governments – so that such regulations can better support organic farming as intended, rather than undermine it.”
Read the full study, or watch the webinar recording (hosted by SWISSCO).